Home » Education, Featured, My Path, Philosophy

Investing vs Working plus a Simple Path to Wealth

August 31, 2009 4:24 pm by Dean Morel

Yesterday while discussing the cost of ownership I had to rein myself in from diverting onto investing versus working. As I mentioned my friend Paul has asked me a couple time whether I’m earnings more via investing than if I worked. I began to discuss two topics which I’ll now cover in some detail.

My Simple Path to Wealth

I’ve read copious wealth and self help books over the years. Not because I care about money, but because I wanted to make sure money was never something I had to care about. It all started with one sentence from my friend Penny. We were at this totally cool and weird party, Ivan in his codpiece splendor had finished singing and gyrating on the old bank counter. I’d love to share a photo, but I only have an ever lasting mental image…thanks for that Ivan!  Anyway, Penny said something along the lines of she was sure I’d be rich. Despite having no money, since I’d not long returned from a two month holiday in North and Central American and was still recovering from viral meningitis, I thought yeah she’s right.

As I was still to weak to work, I spent a lot of times pondering my future during those days and thinking about what Penny had said. I knew I loved Dino time (my time) and wanted to maximise that over my life. So I concentrated on how to achieve financial freedom as enjoyably, quickly and with as least risk as possible, with a goal to ultimately living where ever I wanted and working for others as little as I could. My goal is actually unimportant, the important thing is coming up with a goal. The first step to goal setting is getting to know yourself, what’s important to you and what you truly want out of life. My view is not many people take the time to do that. Perhaps I was lucky getting meningitis and almost dying. My recuperation provided me the time to sit and think, to ponder what was important to me and what I wanted. Contemplating your goals is the best time you’ll ever spend.

Step One: Write down a list of what’s important to you. Without that you’ve got little chance of ever being happy.

More broadly speaking anytime you have a major decision to make write down a list. Jot down all the pros and cons, give each a score of importance and then tot up the score. It’s amazing how this simple task clears the mind and makes difficult decisions easier. Despite knowing this and using it many times I still occasionally find myself wasting weeks fretting about a decision when in less than hour I could make the best decision using this simple strategy. Embrace the power of lists!

Step Two: Make a plan. I’ve mentioned this before, but plans are so important I’m happy to say it all again. While many financial advisors, commentators and bean counters focus on budgets and encourage people to draw up budgets I do not. That’s right screw that budget up right now! Budgets are like diets. They deny you the things you want and have a useless short term nature. I have no idea why people think budgets or diets will work. They don’t. You must associate good things with what you want to achieve. Positive things, which will inspire you. You must think and act and plan long term, budget and diets setup exactly the wrong patters. That is why planning and saving are so important, just as eating healthily and exercise are important if you want to loose weight.

Plans don’t need to be complicated. For many years I used simple bubble diagrams with a five year time frame. While the plan was all text and mainly figures, putting it inside six monthly bubbles along a timeline tricked my graphically oriented partner into thinking I was displaying her the plan, rather than just listing bullet points chock full of numbers. That was our big picture plan. A one page document with ten bubbles with 4-5 bullet points in each.

You need to work out what type of plan will most motivate you. I recommend a five year plan with six monthly targets as a starting point.

Step Three: Make it so. Once you know what you want and have a plan making it happen almost seems to take care of itself. Once again what I did is not really important, but I’ll quickly tell you in case you’re stuck as to where to start. My plan was very simple. I figured out how to maximise my income, how to save as much as possible of that income and how to invest it to achieve a good return. See I said it was simple. It may be more difficult to figure out how to maximise your income depending on you employment, but in most jobs all you have to do is open you eyes. Look around you and see who with your skills is earning more than you and how they’re doing it. For me that meant becoming a contractor.

None of this should seem daunting. I didn’t come up with the entire plan one day. It evolved over the years as I walked along my path. Once you know what you want and start planning you’ll enjoy it so much you’ll keep planning and thinking about what you want.

The only thing that has remained constant with me is time. I continue to enjoy Dino time. The most important point behind all of this is the topic of time. Make time your friend, make time work for you. The sooner you start on your path the better. One of the most important things I learnt about retirement is that it takes at least 15 years to achieve once you make retirement a goal. Sadly most people leave it way to late.You need to make sure time isn’t running away from you.

As I mentioned yesterday all of this becomes a lot easier if you understand and appreciate compounding. Nothing ever seems to happen in the first ten years of compounding on a forty year scale, on a graph the line barely moves above the starting point. However, you are laying the foundations and will see the results in the final ten years of those forty years. Take a look at the graph below for an example. You must focus on the last ten years, your plan’s outcome and not on the drudgery of your current budget, if you haven’t screwed it up already. Check out Wealth and Happiness and Is retirement running away from you? for more on this topic.

Investing vs Working

As I said yesterday, my short answer for Paul on whether I earn more from investing than I would by working is ‘absolutely not’. If I returned to business consulting I’d earn significantly more than I currently do by investing. The long answer is ‘absolutely yes’. Through investing I’ll earn significantly more.

The long answer is that I expect through my focus on investing and constant endeavour to improve my investing I will ultimately be better off financially and I’ll enjoy the trip along the way a lot more. I love investing as I’m a competitive A type freakazoid and investing pits my skills against some of the brightest people in the world. I enjoy investigating companies. It’s much more fun looking at companies from 1,000 feet and thinking about their future than trying to advise them on how to manage their projects, control their costs or capitalise their assets. Companies shape the future and getting to know them gives me visibility into the future, which is gold to a future thinker like me.

Investing lets me stay at home and be with my kids as they grow up. Though they’d probably argue investing keeps me glued to my computer! Investing lets me tend and enjoy my beloved garden, have a yummy dinner on the table each night and take holidays whenever I want. That’s the stuff I enjoy. Investing also lets me do other dull stuff like our shopping and laundry so we have all weekend to enjoy being a family. In short investing dramatically improves my own and my families quality of life.

Here some financial details assuming a starting fund of $1 million, 3% outperformance to an index returning 10% and net income of $60k available to be saved after accounting for tax and other expenses associated with work, like childcare, clothes, incidental expenses.

  • After nine years you’ll be earning more from your outperformance that you would be from working.
  • After eighteen years your gross wealth will be greater.
  • After 45 years your wealth will be twice as much.

If the outperformance end up being 5% then those figure change to three years, six years and 28 years. An 8% outperformance, which would make you a superstar legend investor so you probably shouldn’t count on it, though many retail investors deludedly think that’s achievable, you’ll end up a multi-billionaire. Now I should say I’ve ignored tax in my calculations, but that wouldn’t affect the overall picture too much. [Update: I've now built tax into the spreadsheet and it does change the picture considerably. Investing doesn't come off as well, but still come out ahead.]

The money is pretty meaningless to me, but it’s a handy score keeper which I can ultimately use for my benefit and the benefit of things I care about. In fact I think investors who focus on the money are at a serious disadvantage and I laugh every time I see someone say, ‘just make money‘. Money is the root of fear and greed and they are two massive disadvantages to overcome.

Investing vs Working - Power of Compounding

The above graph starts with one million dollars at forty and uses a 3% outpeformance over an index. You can download the spreadsheet here and play around with it using figures meaningful to you. You may think it’s pretty useless, as it’s based on assumptions like $1M, being able to obtain 3% outpeformance and future income, but at the very least I hope it helps you understand the power of compounding.

If you enjoyed reading this you might enjoy one of my early posts from June 2008, Is retirement running away from you? There is a basic retirement calculator embedded in the post, which may be of interest to you. You may also like one of my favourite posts, Wealth and Happiness, and my first on this topic Your Money or Your Life.

As with everything I say, I describe what is right for me. It may not be right for you. Just as there are many paths in investing, there are many paths in life. I hope you’re on or find your path.

Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • MisterWong
  • NewsVine
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Tipd
More on this topic (What's this?)
Interesting Dividend and Investing Sites to Consider
A CLOSER LOOK AT MAGIC FORMULA INVESTING
Read more on How To Invest at Wikinvest

Related posts:

  1. Investing and the Government
  2. Inch Worm – Enjoy the Journey while Planning for the Future
  3. Random Ramblings on Margin, Market Timing and Investing Secrets
  4. Quick Thoughts on Becoming Wealthly
  5. Is Retirement Running Away From You?
  6. Wealth and Happiness

10 Comments »

  • Peter said:

    In essence, financial independence gets you freedom, and such freedom allows you to engage in activities that will make you happy. Like all good things in life, freedom and happiness comes with a price, and the price is the slog towards accumulating and compounding wealth.

    Not too difficult especially if you have time. I am at present trying to get a 25 year old protege, and a 35 year old brother-in-law, to focus on the power of compounding and early retirement. They will end up heaps better than me when they get to my age.

  • Dean Morel (author) said:

    Exactly Peter. You say freedom I say time, it’s the same thing. 25 is a fantastic time to start and 35 isn’t too late, I wish you luck with them, for their sake. Compounding takes so long to work most people struggle to comprehend it. If you find a great way of getting the message across please let me know.
    Interesting times in the Australian market at the moment, particularly weird day today.

  • Peter said:

    It is interesting, and interesting to see how journalist ascribe causes- for today, the SMH says the m arket decline is due to profit taking。 What a revelation。 Getting difficult to find bargains in Buffett terms ie 50% safety margin。  Still some stocks slightly undervalued, but no compelling buys yet。 

    BTW, Istill do not buy the NMS story, but the share price is proving me wrong at this time。

    To fully reap the effects of compounding requires a certain strength of character, and demands patience that youth does not usually endow。 The best way to get the message across is to instill it when one is still a child。  A savings book is still one of th e best。 

  • Dean Morel (author) said:

    Here’s an excerpt from a great post on debt and consumption and a book recommendation.
    “These beliefs have worked very well for me, and I would advise others to consider them. For an individual, as for an economy, it boils down to the fact that debt and/or capital should only be used for buying appreciating assets (investments) and never for depreciating assets (consumption). If you follow this rule, your consumption level will fall behind your neighbors early in your life, but they will be greeting you at Nordstrom’s and driving you around when you get older. Additionally, you will enjoy the financial advantages of a paid-for house and investments accumulating in your accounts plus the happy knowledge that you can support your family through any emergency, as well as the flexibility and freedom that go with financial independence.” http://boards.fool.com/Message.asp?mid=27918679
    and a book that someone recommended on this topic
    http://www.amazon.com/Your-Money-Life-Transforming-Relationship/dp/0140286780

  • max said:

    but you don’t take any living expenses out of your investor option for food and other stuff. in your work scenario you assume 60k net after paying for shelter, food, healthcare, etc…. your wage would probably go up with inflation too.

  • Dean Morel (author) said:

    Hi Max, thanks for your comment. What I said is “available to be saved after accounting for tax and other expenses associated with work, like childcare, clothes, incidental expenses”. So I didn’t take all those costs you indicate out of either working or investing. You could easily modify the spreadsheet if that’s appropriate for you, it’s not for me.
    I did account for wages going up, I assumed 3% a year, but I left that as a variable for people to change as they see fit.
    The larger point is that by looking at the bigger longer picture a different picture emerges than by concentrating on the here and now. Investing is all about giving something up now for a future return. You must look at the long term, big picture.

  • James Cox said:

    Great post Dean, Really enjoyed it. As a 24 year old with ~80k saved, I’d be interested in hearing how you went from zero to $1 million.

    Keep it up :)

  • James Cox said:

    I ask this because (as im sure you know), Working will dominate investing until you have enough capital for the investing returns to be big enough to cover the costs of your life.

    See attached graph i made from your spreadsheet.. (thanks for making it)

    http://img193.imageshack.us/i/24yearold.jpg/

  • Dean Morel (author) said:

    Hi James,
    Thanks for you comment. Great job accumulating $80k by 24. At 24 I had no money and was just starting University, three years after that I was in debt, so you’re way ahead of where I was.
    You’re spot on that working will dominate in your early years. So it is more important to concentrate on maximising your income and controlling your expenses. Saving $80k by 24 means you’re a good saver and should have no problem accumulating wealth over your life. If you haven’t got a five year plan then do one now, concentrating on how you’re going to maximise your income.

    Keep in mind the spreadsheet is very rough. For example the 3% growth you put in only applies to the $15k saved. So if you actually earn $45k a year and save $15k, then you may want to increase the wage growth amount. One of the keys to wealth is to find a level of spending you’re comfortable with and staying at that despite income increases, thus all future wage increases are saved. Of course enjoying life along the way is also important and focusing on money is not a good path to happiness.

    Think of yourself like a business. How can you increase your income, reduce your costs and thus improve your margins while keeping employees happy, that’s you. Write down your strategy and your five year plan. Track your net wealth on a monthly basis, it only takes a couple minutes and I find rather than making your money obsessed actually liberates you from the world wide obsession with money, soon it just becomes numbers. It’s like running or the gym (I imagine as I’ve never really done either of those) you’re setting targets and trying to better them.

    No matter what your profession or trade, there is a way to maximise your income and leverage your skills. You may have to move overseas, start a business, become a contractor or change jobs. Remember practice makes perfect. The best way to get ahead is to practice more than anyone else is. If you enjoy doing what you’re doing then that should be easy. If you don’t like what you’re doing then you need to figure out what you would enjoy.

    Buy appreciating assets when they’re cheap and limit the depreciating assets you buy. Cars are a huge waste of money, try to avoid owning one, you’ll be healthier and the planet will love you. Australian property will be cheap at some point in the future, that’s when I’ll be adding property to our portfolio. Shares are now fairly priced, I’ll increase our exposure when they are cheap again.

    James, $80k at 24 makes you a legend in my book, good luck. Don’t trust anyone with your money, but do seek advice.

  • mlgreen8753 said:

    I don’t see why you can’t do both. Working allows people to funnel earned income into an investment that generates passive income. Eventually you want to do away with a job, but in the beginning it’s ideal. My job has allowed me to acquire numerious assets. I am now self-employed and that allows me to fund investments as well. My latest interest is a stock investment in Mentor Capital (MNTR). Some of my previous assets were a rental property and various Internet businesses.

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.